Tag Archives: audiobook

Becoming an Audiobook Narrator?

Oh… family!

Well, another Thanksgiving has come and gone here in the U.S.!  Many of us spent the holiday with relations, having huge feasts, yelling at the game on T.V., and starting our Christmas shopping.  Not me — I pent five days all to myself — and it was WONDERFUL!  Don’t get me wrong — like you I enjoy a little travel, time with friends and family, and even being involved in the cooking (for obvious reasons) — however I also immensely value my personal time.  For what might not be so obvious … I’m an introvert — I’m glad to spend five days straight doing my own thing and not seeing another soul! Audiobook Narrator

In advance of the holiday weekend I wrote myself a To-Do List. For the most part it was a collection of things that are different from my regular grindstone tasks — and frankly … they were more interesting, too.  As my five-days-alone approached I got excited to dive in on my list.  Oh yeah, I’d planned to make progress on all this stuff, get some time on neglected projects.  So when the first day hit …. yeah, I didn’t really do anything.  The second day went pretty much the same way.  Then I remembered …. every once in a while, take a break!  After two days I forgave myself and then rolled up my sleeves.  Now at the end of my five days most of the list is not marked off, but I’m pleased with things I have done. Audiobook Narrator

But how does this relate to audiobook narration?

Make Your Own Darn Good Cookies
Wanna guess who’s my hand model?

One of the scribbled lines on my To-Do List was to audio record my debut recipe book Make Your Own Darn Good CookiesWhy would I do this?  Well, for one … because I can … and for two, because I’m once again exploring  the idea of becoming a professional Audiobook Narrator.

In Make Your Own Darn Good Cookies I tell the story of how my recipe book came to be — which includes dealing with a hard drive crash 1/2 way through*.  Around that time I had a laugh with my editor — obviously I can read, I have a small collection of recording gear from my other super hero persona as a musician, and I’ve been told I have a nice voice — I could make an audiobook version of my recipe book!!!  The laugh was that I could completely produce this myself at little cost, but who would want to listen to a recipe book?!?  … And then I found some recipe books that ARE also available in audiobook form.  The laughter stopped and the research began.
* NOTE — Back-up your hard drive.

Life Of The Audiobook Narrator

Long-story-short … audiobook narrators are work-from-home contractors who get paid to read books aloud and prepare their finished recordings for the client.  Tons of information about the industry is available online.  If you dig down you can find the ‘realities of the industry‘ as well.  While many articles sing the praises of the work and tell you what’s involved, only some of them break down the hard numbers and tell you what you didn’t know or maybe don’t want to hear.  Me … I DO want to get that part of the picture.  Twice before I’ve toyed with the idea, lately I’ve been taking a hard look at it again.

Getting Ready

I’ve read additional articles and listened to numerous audiobook narrators objectively to understand what they do in their performances.  To ‘cut my teeth’ I’ve decided to finally record Make Your Own Darn Good Cookies to see what I think — and to finally produce the audiobook version so I can release it with the upcoming new cover-art for the book and e-book.

Last night I practiced reading some of my recipe book aloud. Something about it felt better than when I last gave it a go (which, unrelated, I did during a power outage because I had little else to do). This time it felt more natural and confident …. no idea why. All I can think of is that I’ve had nearly a year of listening to additional audiobooks — when I listen it’s not only for entertainment and interest, part of me also tries to observe what the author is doing. Perhaps part of it too is that I’ve listened to about 1/2 a dozen topical books since spring 2021 — straight reading which the narrators need to bring out as opposed to working with a diversity of characters in fiction.  A recipe book requires straight reading, which a good narrator will give intonation to keep it interesting to the reader.

I just finished about 30 minutes of recording work and I’m about to listen to the playback.  I feel good about this.  Let’s see how it goes …

But What About Recipe Books?!?

Yes, I had a production baking business.  Yes, I switched to writing recipe books.  Yes, I am also a professional musician.  And, yes, I like to eat and have bills to pay.  I have been working to get work since closing the production baking — clearly with little luck.  Frankly folks, writing and selling books alone is not enough — BiscottiDon needs a day-job.  My passion for baking, cooking, and writing (and playing bagpipes) does not change with working a day-job.  In fact, I have 3 new recipe books nearing completion — publishing around spring 2022.  I’ve been interested in getting a work-from-home position, and audiobook narration looks like it could be a good fit!

DIY Audiobook Recording

NOTE — I wrote this post a number of weeks before publishing and at present it is unfinished.  The feedback I received from my previous similar-post is that I had a well written article with good information.  If this is the case, I would rather have this +90% article published and potentially helping people VS sitting in the unpublished private section of my site.  You will see the unfinished sections in red-bold font.  Please check back for updates. ~ Don 

You might remember when I recently published a blog post titled “Record Your Own Audiobook“.  From time to time I see authors online who what it would take for them to record their book themselves.  A few years ago I researched becoming an audiobook narrator.  While I am no expert, and I am yet to wade into these professional waters, I learned a lot.  I thought to write this primer so that other authors can understand what will be ahead, and to consider if this venture is right for them.

Originally I had the idea of narrating my recipe book “Make Your Own Darn Good Cookies” while talking with my editor.  Something registered in a moment of shared laughter – as a musician* I have recording gear, I’m obviously literate, and I’m told that I have a decent voice.  What was funny to me was the idea of a recipe book in audiobook form.  Who would do that?  … and soon after I started finding other recipe books that were available in playback form.
*My musical endeavours include BagpiperDon, Nae Regrets, and Archive Of Resonance.

So assuming that you are totally new to the idea of recording your audiobook yourself, here we go …

Studio

You will need to find a decent location to record.  With any luck you can do this in your own home, but what is most important is how the space sounds.  You need a room without noise, noises, or noise intrusion.  What we’re going to talk about here is not going to produce an ideal studio but something that ought to be workable and affordable.

Noise Intrusion

Disliked or unwanted sounds are what we tend to call ‘noise’.  Trust me on this ‘unwanted/disliked sound’ concept — I am a musician and I’ve heard it from folks on good days — it is an opinion.  Things you can hear from inside your intended recording space that are unwanted are intrusive noise.  When you’re recording, if you have housemates, you are going to need have them not run vacuums, TVs, or anything outside of your studio that you can hear inside.  A car racing up the street blaring a stereo is going to require you to stop and start over from before the interruption.  You can do a few things to mitigate these problems, but if there are too many ‘unwanted sounds’ where you want to record, you’re going to have to get resourceful and find somewhere else that might be available to you.  You might be able to make arrangements with churches, offices, or other places.  You might also need to offer a trade, hopefully putting the establishment in the acknowledgements section of your audiobook will suffice.

Room Noises

Go into the room you plan to use.  Turn on the lights, your computer, the heating or air conditioning, whatever it is you think you’re going to have going in your space while recording. Get quiet, close your eyes, whatever you need to do – the important thing is that you listen!

Do you hear the light?  The heater or AC?  Do you have a phone in the room?  Can you hear a fan on your computer?  Whatever it is, you need to identify these and make adjustments.  Change what lights you’re going to use.  Instead of reading your manuscript on a computer, print it out or put it on an e-reader.  Sit in your chair and listen – does the chair creak, does the floor?  Make adjustments, get quiet, listen, make adjustments as necessary.  This is also a good time to listen for intrusive noises again.

Something else to think about – and this may come from what I know about recording music – is if anything with your clothing is making noise.  The soles of your shoes … body shifts making garment sounds … jingly jangly jewelry … anything.  Take off your shoes, wear soft clothes, remove those flashy bits of metal.

Also think about anything that might be in the room that you’re okay with, that you think might add character to your recording, that you might think the people listening to your audiobook would enjoy.  Perhaps you plan to read on your couch next to the fire while your cat comfortably languishes on your lap.  You might think that’s nice, but your customer might get rather distracted from your reading hearing intermittent purring, surprising pops and cracks from the fire, or yourself shifting around on that couch that you didn’t notice has a squeak until you recorded on it.  Remember that your end-customer is going to be listening for numerous hours – the more that is a pleasant experience for them the more likely they are to finish your audiobook and listen to your next one.

A Room Without Noise

Some of what will affect the quality of your recording is the character of your room.  If there is an echo in the room there will be an echo in your recording.  In some cases a little echo is good, but in most cases it is bad.  If you need an echo it’s better to put it in during post production; if you have an echo in your source recording it is difficult if impossible to remove it.

So how do you identify a room with an echo and how do you fix it?  First, you cross your fingers that your efforts will help, then get to work…

The best way I know to identify an echo in a room is to go in, get quiet, and clap!  Listen for an echo.  If there is a substantial echo, you might want to experiment with other rooms the same way.  If you only noticed a slight echo then it’s time to roll up your sleeves.  Put down an area rug if the floor is a hard surface.  When it comes to the walls, irregular surfaces should help to cut down sound – bookshelves, couches, et cetera.  If you still need to cut down some bouncing auditory wavelengths, hang some blankets on the walls – loose is better than flat.

Recording Gear, Software,
& Your Computer

While recording directly to a computer is an option, it isn’t my preference.  I rather use my portable recording gear and a microphone.  Let’s take a look at both…

Computer

If you are going to record directly to a computer you’re probably going to need a few things.  Likely any microphone on-board a portable computer will be inadequate.  A traditional microphone will not connect to your computer without some sort of interface.  Microphones that that are better than your on-board mic and will plug into your mic/line-in port (3.5mm headphone jack) are available and quite affordable.  I have one I purchased for $50 – generally, but not always, the more you spend the better you get.  You are also going to need software … and learn to use it at least at a basic level … and get your computer, mic, and software all to work together.  I’ll talk about a few software options at the end of this section, including 1-3 that are free.

Recording Gear

These days the recording gear available on the market is relatively affordable and produces high quality recordings.  There are a number of brands, models, and prices available.

When I started shopping my options I got turned on to Zoom products.  I already had one of their MRT-3b drum machines; I was impressed with its ease of use and overall performance.  Getting a Zoom H4 recording unit was an easy choice.  I now have a H4n (about $300) and H2n (about $200).  Both of these are intuitive to use after a short amount of time with the manuals, have solid state memory, on-board microphones, and use wall or battery power.  Transferring my recordings to my computer is just a matter of a USB cable or pulling the SD card out of the recording unit – USB is faster and easier.

When it comes to choosing which unit to record with I would be content to use the H2n with its onboard mics set to L/R stereo (it can record 4 channel).  My preference, however, would be to use my H4n.  While it has stereo mics I would attach one of my voice mics (with cables I have about $300 invested between new and used elements).  Each of these units will record in various audio formats.  Understanding that your audiobook will be recorded for distribution first and foremost in CD format, you will want to set your unit for WAV at (FIDELITY?).  When this gets converted to download format it will be converted to MP3 (FIDELITY?).  (You may want to give some further thought to your recording fidelity in the event you are featuring music or sound effects behind your narration.)

Mics, Cables, and Pop Filters
I HAVEN’T WRITTEN THIS YET

… and if you get a mic you’re going to want a mic stand — because you will quickly tire of holding a mic.  Also, learn about how to position your mic for optimum performance.  With the most common style of microphone, people will often talk into these like they are licking the side of an ice cream cone — that would be wrong and the pick-up is usually poor — align the body of the mic perpendicular to your mouth and Go For It!  However, ideally you would be using a different style of microphone and you need to learn where its field of pick-up is.  Ask your salesperson, read the manual, look on the box, look it up online, sometimes the sound diagram is indicated on the microphone body, ask questions.

Software & Your Computer … and noise

Whether you record on a separate unit, like those above, or on your computer you are going to need studio software.  While there are industry standards (like Cubase and Pro Tools), they tend to be expensive – and you have to learn at least the minimum to make them function to produce an audiobook.  Another option is Audacity, which is free and fairly straightforward to operate.  Depending on your operating system, you may already have some studio software (Apple Garage Band, Linux Ubuntu) available to you.  When you are done recording your book you’re also going to need to use your studio software to fix your mistakes – connecting up your takes and re-takes when you stumbled on words or any other mistakes you will make (in the business these edits are known as punch-ins).

Make sure that your computer can handle the studio software.  If you are recording directly to your computer you will also need to make sure that it can handle both the data speed while recording and has the storage space for your audio files.  Another thing to consider if you are recording directly to a computer is any noise it makes.  It may produce fan noise, which is difficult to mask – and if you do mask this noise it can also be at the risk of making your machine overheat.  If you intend to read your manuscript from your computer you may also be dealing with noise from your keyboard.  Again, this is why I prefer working with autonomous recording units.  Also, I like the idea of having my manuscript printed out on paper over being on an e-reader.  The reason for this is that I can write cues or annotations, or use coloured pens so I can see what’s coming in the reading.  And when it’s all done, the paper can be recycled – even better, use the backs of all the pages for note paper first.

Practical Work
& Time Involvement

So now you’re ready to put the ‘personal touch’ on your audiobook just like Carrie Fisher.  But how do you speak when reading your book aloud?  You could get yourself some voice lessons, just like Princess Carrie had – but many of us don’t have the time or budget for this … and yet you do want to do a good job.  So what do we do?  We go to the internet!

Do some research online.  Even if you are not looking to become a professional audiobook narrator there is quite a bit of information from the pros that applies to folks like you and me.  I suggest reading articles on Karen Commins &/or Paul Strikwerda‘s websites.  Also, listen to podcasts about audiobook narration on Joanna Penn’s website (7 Reasons to Narrate your Own Audiobooks with Joanna Penn).

Get your hands on some audiobooks narrated by top-notch readers.  Look for big names like Scott Brick and Dick HillWil Wheaton from Star Trek Next Generation has also done a lot of work.  Listen to these narrators objectively for how they read – how they emote, how they develop different characters, and how they pace their reading.  Take some cues from these examples and practice reading yourself.

A professional audiobook narrator takes around 4 hours to read what produces 1 finished hour of material.  ‘Finished’ means audio that has been fixed up — re-recordings for misspoken words, interruptions (grumbling hungry tummy, bathroom breaks?), et cetera.  The average romance or sci-fi novel will be 8 to 9 hours of finished recorded material — so let’s assume 9.  4 hours per hour X 9 finished hours = 36 hours of work ….. for a professional.

Be prepared that you will probably take longer than a professional audiobook narrator.  Most authors reading their own work will take longer to complete the project than an experienced professional.  We know how our books sound to us and we will read, re-read, and edit the audio until it sounds right.  Remember one of the sayings I’ve picked up – “Don’t let ‘good’ be the victim of ‘great’.

Anyone reading out loud needs to pace themselves.  Vocal fatigue will take its course, so don’t plan to read for 8 hours at a go – not even the professionals do this!  If there is a 1:4 ratio involved in reading and fixing up the recordings, perhaps figure on recording for 15 minutes and then fixing the audio for 45-60 minutes.  This will give your voice a chance to rest; also, if you are scheduling your time around your day-job and personal life, this will help you to cut off a reasonable chunk every day.

When your recording is complete it needs to get mastered.  Mastering is a part of post production where the audio is retouched to sound its best and then transferred from the original source to the master — the data source which will be used to produce all copies of the final product.

While it is not unheard of for an author to record their own audiobook, from what I’ve seen it isn’t common.  If you’re like me, I like it when I can listen to the author read their own book.

I hope this helps — Good Luck!
Don

Record Your Own Audiobook?

Last week on Twitter one of the authors I’m connected with posed a question about audiobooks — a question I run into from time to time.  C.S. Ratliff wrote “#writingcommmunity How risky is it to record your own audiobook?”  A few years back I did a considerable amount of research toward becoming an audiobook narrator — so I took some time to reply to his question.

To to be specific, Mr. Ratliff asked about the ‘risk’ involved with an author recording themselves reading their own book.  As said — he asked about the risk, not what’s involved to accomplish the recording — so I would like to come back to this topic at the end of the article.

So what’s involved …

BagpiperDonI first got the idea of narrating my recipe book, Make Your Own Darn Good Cookies — frankly — having a laugh with my editor!  It all makes sense though…  As a musician* I already have more than enough recording gear…  Obviously, I’m literate…  Last, but not least, I’m told that I have a good voice.  Outside of that, you just need to find a decent sounding location — a room without noise or other things like echos.
* As music and audio things go I am also @BagpiperDon, @NaeRegrets, and @AOResonance and I do all the recording for those projects.

Studio

Home StudioOne option is to record in a studio.  A studio like what musicians use to record albums are not only more than what you need, they are also really expensive!  The last I checked — which was 1-2 decades ago — if you could find something around $100/hr that was on the inexpensive end.  This is what motivated me to get my own gear and learn how to use it for recording my albums.

If you check around you might be able to find someone with a small home-studio.  While this would be ideal it can have a lot of variables.  First, assuming this is not a friend who’s happy to spend their time recording you for the sake of friendship and dinners, the expense is quite likely prohibitive for most of us.  If this is not a friend’s home, then you’re going to be spending quite a bit of time in someone else’s abode — and that can get awkward.  Depending on who you’re dealing with, it may be a perfectly workable studio but also could be a dump.

MONEY!Calculate this…
A professional audiobook narrator takes around 4 hours to read what produces 1 finished hour of material.  ‘Finished’ means audio that has been fixed up — re-recordings for misspoken words, interruptions (hungry tummy, bathroom breaks?), et cetera.  The average romance or sci-fi novel will be 8 to 9 hours of finished recorded material — so let’s assume 9.  4 hours per hour X 9 finished hours = 36 hours of work ….. for a professional (I’ll come back to the difference between a professional and an author doing the reading).  The last I checked, an audiobook narrator who is new to the business costs $42/finished hour of recording.  So that 9 hours of finished recording (for this part of the work) will cost you $378.  So your nearly-40 hours of work — providing you can do the work of a professional — saves you nearly $400.  How does that compare to a week’s pay in your day-job?

So if you have the money or a friend and you use a studio of one sort or another, when your recording is complete it needs to get mastered.  Mastering is a part of post production where the audio is retouched to sound its best and then transferred from the original source to the master — the data source which will be used to produce all copies of the final product.

Recording Gear, Software, and Recording Space

Zoom H2n
Zoom H2n

Instead of paying a professional you could buy recording gear.  These days there is gear available on the market that is easy to use, relatively affordable, and will produce high quality recordings.  I’ve seen some authors online say that ‘all it takes is buying a microphone’.  You can find microphones that will plug directly into your computer … but … does your computer make any (fan) noise?  If you’re reading your manuscript on your computer at the same time, does your keyboard make noise?  Do you have fast and large enough data storage?

I have a Zoom H2n and H4n.  Both of these have solid state memory, on-board microphones, and the option of using wall or battery power.  Providing I had a good space to record in, I would be content to use the H2n.  Since I have a number of good voice-mics I would attach one to my H4n — while this would probably produce a better recording, mostly I would go with this option simply because I have the gear.  I spent about $500 to get these 2 recording units — I use them frequently and for various applications.  Remember that $400 amount earlier?  Is this a purchase that makes sense to you for something you might only use once, or with publication of each book?

Whether you record on a separate unit, like those above, or on your computer you are going to need studio software.  While there are industry standards (like Cubase and Pro Tools), they tend to be expensive — and you have to learn at least the minimum to make them function to produce an audiobook.  Another option is Audacity, which is free and fairly straightforward to figure out how to operate.  When you’re done recording your audio you’re also going to need to use your studio software to fix your mistakes — connecting up your takes and re-takes when you stumbled on words or any other mistakes you will make (in the business these edits are known as punch-ins).

Still, when your recording is completed you are going to need to get it mastered — but that doesn’t address if you should or shouldn’t make your own recording….

To Record Or Not To Record — That Is The Question

Shakespeare's SkullI wrote earlier that Mr. Ratliff asked about the risk involved with an author recording their own audiobook.  I’m frankly not clear what he means with regard to risk, but I have a few ideas …

While it is not unheard of for an author to record their own audiobook, from what I’ve seen it isn’t common.  One famous example of this was Carrie Fisher.  She self-narrated six of her books — among those Wishful Drinking earned her a Grammy Award nomination in 2009, and The Princess Diarist winning a Grammy in 2018.  To be fair, Carrie Fisher had her Star Wars fame behind her and The Princess Diarist was awarded 13 months after her death (<– think about that for a moment).

One of the things that was in Ms. Fisher’s favour is that she had a considerable amount of voice training since getting into acting.  Most authors don’t have this.  She also knew how to make characters, which if you’re reading fiction you need to do with your voice.  Also, you don’t read for an audiobook at the same pace as you read.

There are other various benefits — and detriments — to the author being the voice behind their own book.

  • It puts the ‘personal touch’ on the audiobook.
  • Most authors reading their own work will take longer to complete the project than an experienced professional.  We know how our books sound to us and we will read, re-read, and edit the audio until it sounds right.
  • Another benefit to using a professional is that they will get the job done while you are working on your writing.

So Is Self-Recording Right For You?

ThinkingNo one can answer that question but you.  It’s not impossible but for most authors it’s more work than they care to bite off.  This should help give you things to consider and know about.

If you want to do more research go online!  Even if you are not looking to become a professional audiobook narrator there is quite a bit of information that applies from the pros.  I suggest you start with reading Karen Commins &/or Paul Strikwerda‘s websites.

I hope this helps — Good Luck!
Don

PS — This article “Do it Yourself: A 10-Step Guide to Self-Publishing an Audiobook” was written a little over 2 years ago.  It’s a bit out of date however I think it still asks some important questions to consider.

Eldritch Black and Weirdbey Island

Eldritch Black
This fellow …

Exactly ten days ago, as you will recall from my recent blog post, I met at a local coffee shop with one Mr. Eldritch Black.  A rather curious gentlemen and fellow author here on Whidbey Island, Mr. Black writes creepy books for the purpose of scaring youngsters.  We’ve asked him not to do this terrible thing, however the children seem to enjoy these tomes of his, so I guess it’s all for the better. Weirdbey Island

Since becoming an author myself just over a year ago with “Make Your Own Darn Good Cookies, I’ve had the blessing (and sometimes curse) of connecting with numerous other authors.  Quite a few have kindly shared their works, most often in the form of e-books — some with audiobooks.  Over the past year I have received so many of each I can’t keep up with them.  Mr. Black generously foisted some of his upon me — two from his Weirdbey Island series along with The Book of Kindly Deaths.

Pirates of Penn CoveA few months ago I had the opportunity to listen to the first of the Weirdbey Island books — The Pirates of Penn Cove.  Despite Mr. Black’s purpose of scaring children, I being an adult found I rather enjoyed the story.  His story of Island newcomer, Dylan, was unsettling at every turn — and the locations were written much as they are in real life right here on Whidbey!  For his generosity, and whatever possibly twisted reasoning behind it, I wanted to return Mr. Black’s courtesy with my online review.

The Day of the JackalopeToday I started Weirdbey Island book #2 — The Day of the Jackalope — and it’s already off to a bizarre and unnerving start.  Dylan is with his friends leading their own investigations into the mysterious going-ons on Whidbey Island.  These books have been a delight for the sheer sake that they remind me of the creepy books I read as a kid.  It is a nostalgia-blast that takes me back to the first two books of the Bunnicula series.

As time permits I will listen to the audiobook copy of The Book of Kindly Deaths … not that I really want to, I just want to make sure the children out there are safe. Weirdbey Island

This has been an attempt to write in similar style to the story-telling you will find in these first few Weirdbey Island books.  Frankly, they’re a lot of fun, and I hope you and the children in your life will enjoy them as much as I have.  Both of the Weirdbey Island books above are delightfully narrated by J. Scott Bennett.
~ Best, Don

Eldritch Black ~ Links

Homepage – Amazon – Goodreads
Twitter – Facebook – Instagram

J. Scott Bennett ~ Links

Audible worksGoodreads – Twitter – Facebook

Back to WORK – Bill Millin and D-Day

Bill Millin plays bagpipes for soldiers, 1944
Bill Millin plays his pipes for fellow soldiers in 1944.

This past summer got BUSY … and interesting!  As many of you know I had a few adventures as a professional SCUBA diver, working at various locations around western Washington.  While it was great to get back in the water and blow bubbles, it also required me to shift my priorities.  Big among those priorities was the completion of my second bookAs many of you ALSO know this project is a Highland bagpipe sheet music & tune history book I am writing as a fundraiser for a veteran’s organization I am a member of.  There are a few chunky tasks remaining before publication.  The most challenging of these is writing about Bill Millin, a bagpiper who played on D-Day.

The legend of Bill Millin is well-known in the Highland bagpipe community.  The short story that everyone knows is that “Piper Bill” went ashore on Sword Beach* — he carried no firearm, wore a kilt, played bagpipes, and never got shot by German forces because they thought he had gone insane.  While all of this is true and I already knew from lore, I have been formally researching the whole story and it is far more detailed.
(*Queen Red, the furthest east section of the invasion)

Bill Millin, Highland bagpipes, landing, Queen Red, Sword Beach.
Bill Millin with his bagpipes landing on the Queen Red section of Sword Beach.

It is an honor to be writing about this man’s role in the June 6, 1944, Normandy invasion and it is important to me that I get it right.  I have reached out for every information source I can locate.  Presently I have a considerable stack of library books on D-Day, audiobooks and e-books, media on order, one film, along with articles and interviews I’ve found online.  Something I am particularly excited about is that I have made contact with Bill Millin’s son and grandson online and they have agreed to review my work once complete.  Also, it seems that each time I stop by the library to pick up another piece of media I’ve ordered, I find and buy a D-Day or WWII book from their used book rack.  Apparently I’m building my own D-Day/WWII library $3 at a time!

The bronze life-size statue of Piper Bill Millin unveiled on 8 June 2013 at Colleville-Montgomery, near Sword, in France.

As I review these history sources I have found some problems in the information.  Generally speaking I have books written by historians and articles written by journalists.  Some of the errors I have identified due to my Highland bagpipe playing career.  Some of the errors seem to be words and concepts the previous writers did not fully understand.  The biggest problem I have been finding is historical inconsistencies.  Generally the greater collection of errors come from the journalists — these individuals tend to work at a faster pace with less study than historians.  Usually I can sift through the historical inconsistencies by applying information from military documents along with identifying the details that are consistent in history books and interviews from Bill Millin himself.

As said it is an honor to be writing about this man.  It is an honor as a bagpiper and as the grandson of WWII veterans.  My aim is to help clean up some of the history mistakes that have developed and promote the greater story of Bill Millin’s role in D-Day among my piping peers along with my non-piping readers.  I am sure that you too will be impressed by this one aspect of The Greatest Generation and the greatest invasion in the history of the world.

Books and Other Media

Middle-grade and Youth-oriented Books
  • D-Day by Charlie Samuels – Part of the “Turning Points In US Military History” collection, for its target audience this book looked excellent!
  • D-Day / A True Book by Peter Benoit – This book is similar to the Charlie Samuels’ text … only that I’m uncomfortable with a history book that says it is a ‘true’ history book.
  • D-Day / The Invasion of Normandy 1944 by Rick Atkinson – I plowed through the Atkinson book looking for information on my subject.  In my opinion based on the other books I have studied, the author glosses over details and frequently presents them with gross mistakes.
  • D-Day / The WWII Invasion That Changed History by Deborah Hopkinson – I’m frankly disappointed by this book.  Picking it up it appears to be on-par with the work of Cornelius Ryan and Stephen Ambrose (ETC) — the book is large and thick — but that is a first impression only.  Upon closer inspection, as an author I can tell you there are a few tricks that have been used to make the book appear more impressive.  The two main tricks is that the book is not single-spaced and it is loaded with pictures; take out the photos, make it single spaced, and it is half the length at best.  This 2018 publication does not appear to present anything new on the topic and is possibly written in such a manner as to not ‘offend’ the Politically Correct (ETC) crowd &/or to spoon-feed D-Day to the delicate middle-grade blue-ribbon crowd.  The good thing I can say about the book is that it is worth it for accessing the D-Day related pictures … other than that, other books are in my opinion better information sources whereas this one is comparatively watered-down.  And for my uses … no apparent mention of Bill Millin on Sword Beach or at Pegasus Bridge.

If you would like to support my writing endeavours today, please find my book “Make Your Own Darn Good Cookies” on Amazon, Smashwords and their affiliates4 Free Recipes are available if you would like to try before you buy.